Cognitive overload is a natural human response that appears when mental demands exceed the brain’s ability to process information. This moment of overwhelm, especially under stress or rapidly changing conditions, can happen to anyone—from pilots in the cockpit to everyday people navigating complex digital environments. By examining both case studies like Air France Flight 447 and recent psychological research, clear patterns appear that help explain why overload happens and what it means for human performance.
Matthew Bennett of Human Loop has reviewed the material from the flight data and reached new conclusions.
The Science Behind Cognitive Overload
At its core, cognitive overload occurs when the brain meets more information or challenges than it can manage at once. Our cognitive resources—like working memory, attention, and executive function—are limited. When too many tasks, alarms, or competing demands pile up, these mental “buckets” overflow, leading to confusion, mistakes, and even total breakdowns in decision-making.
Scientific findings reveal:
Intense multitasking and rapid decision requirements (common in crisis situations or digital media use) consume attention and memory, leading to errors and loss of situational awareness.
Emotional stress, surprise, or the “startle effect” amplifies overload by narrowing focus and pulling energy away from rational problem-solving.
A Real-World Illustration: The Air France 447 Case
The 2009 crash of Air France 447 highlights overload in the most vivid, tragic way. In just four minutes, three experienced pilots lost control of a functioning plane, despite thousands of hours in the air.
Multiple alarms, rapid shifts from automated to manual flying, and disorienting instrument readings hit the crew all at once.
As each pilot tried to interpret conflicting data, their communication became fragmented. The junior pilot’s abrupt actions went unexplained. The more experienced pilot was lost in reading alarms aloud but missed the bigger picture.
Critically, the saturation of alarms and warnings prevented them from recognizing the true threat—a stalled plane. Their brainpower was depleted, leaving no capacity for prioritizing or coordinated action.
Why Does This Happen? A Human Perspective
Cognitive overload is not a flaw—it's a feature of how the human brain evolved. Our minds are wired for survival in simpler environments: to focus on one threat, solve one problem at a time, and use habits for efficiency. Modern experiences—from complex machinery to relentless digital alerts—can outstrip these evolutionary “settings,” overwhelming the systems that normally keep us safe and effective.
Other findings show:
Overstimulation, such as doomscrolling or constant notifications, leads to emotional exhaustion, reduced memory, and difficulty keeping attention. This is sometimes referred to as “brain rot,” reflecting cognitive and emotional fatigue in a fast-paced world.
Not just crisis workers are affected: adolescents, young adults, and anyone navigating complex digital environments can experience overload, resulting in increased anxiety, mistakes, and reduced resilience.
What Can Be Done?
Awareness is the first step. Recognizing that overload is a widespread, natural response allows individuals and organizations to act:
Limit exposure to unnecessary noise—whether that’s digital alerts, multitasking, or information overload.
Prioritize training that includes real-world scenarios, so responses in a crisis can become more automatic and less draining.
Encourage mindful technology use—curating content, taking breaks, and engaging with the real world to recharge cognitive resources.
Conclusion
Cognitive overload is a universal human reaction when faced with more than the mind can juggle. By understanding its causes and consequences—from tragic accidents to everyday “brain fog”—we can design safer systems and healthier habits that respect the natural limits of the human brain.
Thanks for sharing this article, fascinating and definitely on my page - here's my contribution to trying to cut through some of this overload - https://www.sallypritchett.com/book#tedx